This recording features the Sunday Talk portion of the service. For the full service watch here.
One Flow: Giving, Receiving, and Forgiveness – Rev. Aimee Daniels
DESCRIPTION
Giving and receiving are one flow, not two separate transactions — and forgiveness is what keeps that flow open. This week we explore tithing as a spiritual practice and forgiveness as a powerful tool which clears the way for abundance.
The summary and transcription were auto-generated, please excuse typos, errors and omissions.
SUMMARY
Rev. Aimee Daniels explores the spiritual principles of giving, receiving, and forgiveness as an interconnected flow in life, drawing on teachings from Eric Butterworth and Michelle Wadleigh. Using the water analogy of the Sea of Galilee and the Dead Sea to illustrate circulation versus stagnation, she emphasizes that tithing is not about obligation or magical transactions but a practice that opens awareness to the divine law of giving and receiving. The talk highlights that lack of grace in receiving constitutes a form of selfishness that blocks both giving and receiving, while true giving comes from a consciousness of sufficiency rather than scarcity. Forgiveness is presented as essential to maintaining flow, defined etymologically as giving completely and giving up claims, with the Amish community’s response to the Nickel Mines tragedy serving as a profound example. The talk concludes with an invitation to conscious giving—whether a specific percentage or another practice—and a forgiveness exercise to release what keeps individuals stuck.
TRANSCRIPTION
Rev. Aimee Daniels:
Thank you, Jonathan. And thank you, music team. Paige, I just leaned over to Danny and I said, “I think her voice gets better all the time.” Doesn’t it? Her voice gets better all the time. So Humble and Kind, I love that song. And I chose it because I love the words in it. It was written for his children, I think. It’s about a parent handing a child ways that they should show up in the world. So simple courtesies, gratitude, once you’ve made it, reach down, pull the next person up. And it asks us not to take anything for granted in our lives, which I think it’s a good way to live. And right now I really feel like humble and kind could be a good mantra for the world and for our country. There’s one more line in the song I really like a lot, and that’s the one that tells us not to have bitterness because bitterness keeps us from flying.
So even though this is a talk about giving and receiving, I’m also going to talk about forgiveness because it’s all about how do you keep flow going in your life. So let’s jump in. So I’m going to use a lot of water analogies this morning. You noticed that Jonathan had one in the Eric Butterworth talk. And the reason I chose Eric Butterworth is I kind of went down a geeky rabbit hole about tithing.
Edwin Gaines, Eric Butterworth, everybody else I could find who talked about that spiritual practice. And I landed on Eric Butterworth because I think he’s practical and I think he gets rid of the superstition and the obligation around tithing that I think causes a lot of people to go like when they hear the word. So I’m going to use the water analogy, back to the water analogy. So in the Holy Land, the Jordan River feeds two bodies of water. Up in the north is the Sea of Galilee and the river flows in and the river flows out again and it’s a thriving sea. It’s full of fish and people have lived around its shores for thousands of years. But in the south is the Dead Sea. You’ve probably heard of the Dead Sea. And the same water feeds the Dead Sea, but there’s no circulation in the Dead Sea.
So what happens? The water eventually evaporates. It turns into sort of this mucky, salty thing and very little life is in the Dead Sea.
So the difference is that the water keeps moving. And I think this is a great analogy for us just to think about our lives. Where in my life are things moving and where in my life are they sort of stopped or stagnated? And there’s no judgment in it. We can all pick apart our lives and say, oh, this is working great. Oh, I’m doing terrible here or I’m stuck here. And this is not about judgment. It’s simply about noticing what’s underneath the experience that you’re having. And we’ve been working with prosperous me all month, even though I’m emphasizing Eric Butterworth. So Michelle Wadley teaches that giving, receiving and forgiving are the same flow. And so if any of them get stuck, they all get stuck. So let’s talk about receiving to start with. Eric Butterworth wrote a short piece called The Art of Receiving and in it he says, “In back of every giving must be a receiving.” This is what Jonathan read to from us.
A faucet can only pour because there’s an open pipe behind it, which is connected to a source. And what does it go into? Something that can hold it. Hopefully your sink’s not overflowing and it’s going on the floor, but it goes into a cup or a glass or a pan. And if you think about your own life, who is better at giving than receiving in your own life? Anybody? Why is it hard for us to receive? You ever brush off a compliment or someone offers to help you and you’re like, “No, I’ve got it.” Or someone picks up the check and then you feel obligated to them instead of just grateful and you’re thinking it’s going to bug you till you pay them back. I know some people in my life who can’t let anyone else pick up the tab. That’s interesting. But Eric Butterworth says, “Lack of grace in receiving is simply a form of selfishness.
Lack of grace in receiving is simply a form of selfishness.” And I have to admit when I read that, I kind of went, “Huh, huh, that’s interesting. When you refuse a gift, you block the other person’s giving and you close their faucet too.” And I’ve talked a lot in the past about not wanting to be a bother, not wanting to be independent, forgetting to ask in terms of my own blocking of my receiving. But the idea that not being willing to receive blocks the other person’s giving really strikes me. It’s like, oh, I should be more open. I should be more appreciative to just say, thank you. Yes. Love your help. Sure, buy me dinner, whatever it is. And think about when someone gave you something and they were so excited. It makes me think about little kids. They get so excited when they give.
I have a totally dumb example from my own life, but my sister and I went on this trip. We went on a couple trips like 20 years ago or so, and she was an English professor. She’s retired now, but our trips were kind of a combo of literature and spirituality. So we were in the southern part of England and we were driving, which is very stressful to drive on the wrong side of the road if you’re the driver. Can I just say, you feel so confused all the time. But every time we would see a sheep, my sister would make this annoying buying sound like a sheep. Well, it kind of became a joke between us. It’s still a joke between us. If we see sheep, like if I’m on vacation and I see sheep, I’ll snap a photo and send it to her. And we’ve both given gifts back and forth to each other over the years that are ridiculous sheep gifts, that no one would want to keep.
I was just at her house in Minnesota. I’m like, she’s got them all. That’s so interesting. I once got a black sheep sweater, but that’s another story. But my point is just like, think about how fun it actually is to give and receive. It’s really fun. And Michelle Wadley puts it this way. As you increase your receptivity, you also increase your generosity because giving and receiving are one flow. They rise together. And you can’t pour from a cup, you won’t let anyone fill. You can’t give if you’re exhausted or depleted or whatever else we might say about the times in our life where we’re actually the one who needs a little bit of support.
Butterworth says this is like breathing. He says you cannot live without giving just as you cannot live without breathing. You inhale and you exhale. You don’t just inhale and you don’t just exhale, you inhale and you exhale. And giving and receiving is the same thing. So when we breathe, it’s one breath. When we give and receive, it’s one flow. So now I’m going to talk about the T word tithing. I said that to somebody this morning and they’re like, “What’s the T word?” Clearly I don’t have an issue with it because I’ve been doing it for a long time, but I’m really hoping to dispel some myths this morning about tithing. And I also want to make it clear I’m not giving this talk to ask you to give. I want you to understand the law of giving and receiving in your own life. That’s the most important thing I want you to take away from this, but let’s talk about tithing.
Tithing literally means a 10th. It’s the idea that you take 10% of what comes in and you give it away. And often in spiritual communities, it’s taught with the caveat where you are spiritually fed. And historically it was understood that that meant 10% to the church. Tithing’s really old. It’s older than the Bible. It was practiced in Babylonia, Greece, Rome, all gave a 10th to their temples. And they were actually required. It was more like a tax or sometimes it was a thank you. If someone went out and they had the spoils of war, that’s what the words were when I read it. They would go take the spoils of war 10% and give it to the temple.
And the church and the government weren’t interchangeable though, right? A lot of times it was the same thing. It was the structure that ran the community. The early church didn’t call tithing a law until the year 585, which is interesting. But I like to think about this as the different roads of tithing. And Eric Butterworth is the road in the middle and then there’s kind of two ditches. It’s my analogy. In one ditch, tithing is a law that you obey, that you’re obligated to obey. In the other ditch, which is I think where a lot of new thought teachers are, is you’re kind of making a deal with God. If I give to where I’m spiritually fed to the church, then God will prosper me.
And we can really get in the wrong energy if we’re giving from that place because we’re giving to get. Eric Butterworth, kind of middle of the road, he would say tithing is a practice that opens the flow. And there’s a quote in Malachi that people like to quote like, “Prove me,” said the Lord of hosts, that’s Edwin Gaines thing. And Eric Butterworth says, his take on it is whatever we give, whether it’s our time, our talent, our treasure, our very self, when we give it freely, it proves the law. And what he says, the law, it proves, it’s not the law of tithing. It’s the law of giving and receiving.
In his chapter, A New Look at Tithing, he says, “There’s no magic whatever in tithing. If prosperity or healing follows it, it comes through the law itself.” And he’s referring to the law of giving and receiving. “As you give, so you receive.” And Jesus didn’t teach tithing specifically too. I just want to say that was part of my geeky research that I found out. He taught the same thing as you give, so shall you receive, which is about more than money. It’s about the energy that we’re putting out in the world. What’s the energy I’m putting out? Is it positive? Is it loving? And because that comes back to us.
Butterworth uses the analogy of a child learning to ride with training wheels. So the training wheels don’t make the bike go. They just give the child a sense of balance and momentum while they’re learning. And once they learn, they don’t need the training wheels anymore. But he says tithing is like that. It doesn’t power anything. It just helps us feel the flow until giving becomes natural for us. He says, tithing is not an end, but a helpful means towards the end of living totally in a giving consciousness. So that’s what we’re really going for. We’re going for living in a giving consciousness.
And then he says something you don’t usually hear a minister say. He says, “Institutions too often sell tithings as a way to keep themselves supported and what gets overlooked is teaching people the way to the divine flow.” So that’s why I’m focusing this way this morning. I want to talk about the flow. And he also says that if you tithe with dollar signs in your eyes, then you are more concerned about what you’re going to get from your gift than you are about where you’re giving from. And giving from is the source within us that we know is the truth of who we are. And that’s true whether you’re giving money, time, anything you’re giving should come from the source within you. It should come from your divine inspiration, whatever your definition is of that. So I want you to think about your giving for a second.
If you’re giving or tithing, do you do it to get things or are you doing it to get a greater awareness of divine law?
And that might seem like a silly thing to say. We were at a charitable event Friday night. And I said to Rich on our way home, I said, “It’s so interesting to look at, they did this whole paddle raise thing. Everyone was raising their paddle and if your friend gave, you had to raise your paddle kind of a thing.” And I said, “It’s so funny. I think a lot of serving on not-for-profit boards and a lot of giving in not-for-profits is because people want to be recognized.” And that’s a good example of giving from the wrong place, right? It’s not a gift freely given. It’s just like when we give a gift or someone gives us a gift that has strings attached. Do you ever have that happen to you where someone gives you a gift, but there’s really a string attached? So Eric Butterworth tells a story about a woman who wants to succeed in her job.
And so she believes tithing is magic and she believes that if it works, it’s magic, then everything will change in her office. So she tithes faithfully for months, except she didn’t change how she showed up. So she was late all the time. She didn’t give her full effort. She had a bad attitude, but then she got mad because she’s like, “Well, I’ve been doing my tithing. I didn’t get anything.” Well, she wasn’t giving from a true place of generosity because she was giving money, but she wasn’t giving from her heart. So that’s really an invitation for all of us. How are we showing up?
And he said about her, she tithes, but she doesn’t give. So I started, I’ve said this so many times, I started tithing years ago because in my household, I was taught that it was the right thing to do. My mother was a very big Methodist. She tithed. It was very important to her. Her church was super important to her. And so when I started, I didn’t even know it was a spiritual law. I just though it was something you did. I had no idea until I came into New Thought. And being in this teaching for a while, one of the people whose thinking really impacted me the most about giving was Lynn Twist. She wrote a book you might know of called The Soul of Money, and she talks about scarcity and sufficiency. And we can give and do anything in our life with a mindset of scarcity like, oh my God, there’s not enough.
I’m not enough, whatever. Or we can come from a place of sufficiency, like I’m already enough. Just how I am, I’m enough. I don’t have to meet anybody else’s expectation. I’m enough. I have enough. My life is sufficient. And I like the word sufficiency because I think about when I started my own business, there were really times when I was writing my tithe check and I’m like, wow, I don’t really have very much money right now. And I came back to that idea of sufficiency and I came back to God as my source and that if I believe that, what I need will appear exactly when I need it. That’s what Mother Teresa said. She said she never raised money because what she needed always appeared exactly when she needed it. And so for me, I get to practice through my giving, knowing sufficiency in my life.
Malachi talked about the whole tithe and Butterworth says the whole tithe means all of us, not just our money. It’s really giving the gift of ourselves to the world. Kay Lil Gabron in the prophet says, “You give but little when you give of your possessions. It is when you give of yourself that you truly give.” Love that quote. Malachi promises that God will open the windows of heaven. Eric Butterworth reminds us that in our teaching, heaven’s not up there someplace. Heaven’s in us. Heaven is within us. Heaven is within you. So the windows of heaven are within you. What does that mean? I think a great definition of prosperity is wellbeing, right? When we know that spirit is our source and we know that there is sufficiency in this universe, we feel a sense of wellbeing. At least I do. Anybody else? Okay. So tithing is not a law, but it’s a technique for fulfilling the law of giving.
And he says that people who give from joy instead of obligation end up giving more and at the end of the year, they look back and maybe they did give more than a 10th, but that’s what he talks about. So I like the words conscious giving, and that’s actually my invitation to you. When we say we’re tithing, someone’s going to assume that means we’re giving 10%.
So if that’s not a practice you want to take on, just practice conscious giving. Decide what that is for you. I think it’s good to have a number that we say like, okay, I’m going to take 2%, 5%, whatever your number is, and I’m going to consciously give that. What I like about having a percentage is that then it makes you mindful. One of the things I’ve really appreciated about this month is I auto give at Cityside. And so it’s easy when you auto give to become unrelated to what’s coming in. And like this week I had a couple things come in and I’m like, “Oh, I need to tithe on those.” And so it’s reminded me, it’s like I want to pay attention to what’s coming and I want to be related to the flow so that I can be grateful for it. So whatever you decide, I think the most important thing is that you just make a decision and you practice it because whatever we practice, whatever habits we have in our life, that’s what happens.
It’s true with any spiritual practice, right? If you commit to meditating and you say, “Do that every morning,” then it’s part of your life. It’s part of your routine. I think giving should be the same thing. And so I want to also just speak to one thing this came up in my thinking as I was preparing. If you struggle to give, and I’m speaking primarily financially right now, I think it’s a wonderful opportunity to just really examine what’s behind that. Maybe you were taught something about scarcity as a child or there’s some other story living in you about flow in your life. And so we do have this month after service, we’re doing a prosperous me thing. If you want to dive into that a little more, we’re going to do that after service. You’re free to drop in even if you haven’t signed up for the class.
So let’s pivot to forgiving now. I don’t want to leave out forgiving. So giving, receiving, forgiving are the same flow. Let’s talk about forgiveness. The word forgive in old English meant to give completely to give up a claim. So to forgive is to give completely, to give up a claim. So forgiveness itself is a kind of giving. And you think about the Lord’s prayer, which many of you might have been taught growing up, forgive us our debts as we forgive our debtors. He used money language, but a grudge is a debt, right? A grudge is a debt we keep trying to collect, right? Like you wronged me, you owe me something.
It’s like you have an IOU from someone and you refuse to tear it up. And it stops us. Bitterness is a song said, bitterness keeps us from flying. A grudge does not weigh down the person who hurt us. They probably don’t even know. They might not even know that they hurt us. Louis Smeads said it this way, “To forgive is to set a prisoner free and discover that prisoner was you.” So it’s pretty humbling. In October 2006, a man walked into a one room Amish schoolhouse in Nickel Mines, Pennsylvania and he shot 10 girls. Some of you might remember that five of them died and then he took his own life. And what did the Amish neighbors do? They went over to the house of the family that afternoon to comfort them. And when money came, they went to the funeral. When money came in to support their community, they made sure that the widow and the children got something.
And that’s a perfect practice of forgiveness. I mean, I look at that and I think I would not have been ready to do that that same afternoon. How about you? I don’t think I would’ve been ready. So you think about your own life. I was trying to think about what’s the biggest grudge I ever had against someone. I was trying to think about that as I was preparing. Maybe my ex-husband, I thought of a few other people, but we all have places in our lives where maybe we hold a grudge or we carry something with us, right? So if you’re repeating a grievance in your head all the time about someone or something, you need to forgive it. You need to let it go because it keeps you stuck in whatever that story is, that’s not the story you’re in now. I remember years ago I dated someone, I might have told this story before, and his ex-wife had had an affair with his best friend and he didn’t know till later.
He found out like six months later. And then 15 years later when I was dating him, he said, “This guy wants to come talk to me now. I mean, I don’t want to talk to him.” And I go, “He moved on with his life. You did not move on with yours. You’re still mad at him, right? You’re still mad at him.” And he did agree to talk to him. It didn’t give him any real great relief to be honest, but at least he let it go. But we all have examples of that, don’t we? Where we’re carrying something around. In the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus says, “If you are bringing a gift to the altar and you remember that someone has something against you, leave your gift on the altar, go reconcile with the person and then come back and offer your gift.” And so the forgiveness comes before the giving.
If we’re giving and our hearts closed in some way, we’re not flowing. And I don’t know. I’m just going to say a personal example of forgiveness, which I’ve talked about this there. I had something going on with a member of my family for a long time, which is so unlike me, right? So unlike me, but the person wasn’t available to have a conversation with me. And every time I though about him, it made me feel bad. It made me feel… And I had reached out over the years, but eventually it got cleared. But my point is just when we’re holding something, we’re stuck, right? And sometimes you aren’t going to choose to be in relationship with someone. In my case, of course, it’s my nephew, I am, but like an ex, you might not say, oh yeah, I’m going to go be their best friend or anything, but at least you’ve let it go.
Butterworth says the whole tithe, the commitment to work with the law in every part of our life includes forgiving until 70 times seven. So continuously forgiving. Forgiveness is part of giving the whole tithe, which is giving your whole self really is the whole tithe. And we’re not saying what happened is okay. We’re just saying we’re ready to move on with our lives. I like the way Desmond Tutu teaches us. He described forgiveness as a path. You tell the story, you name the hurt, you grant forgiveness, and then you choose to either renew the relationship or you choose to release it. It’s your choice. But forgiveness releases this claim. It doesn’t mean you give up your boundaries or anything like that. It just means that you freed yourself up from whatever happened in the past. Edwin Gaines, who’s been very popular and I chose not to speak about, talks about her own personal experience with forgiveness.
And she said as she did, and the reason I chose not to talk about her, I just want to be clear about this, is because her teaching kind of teaches tithing more like it’s this magical thing and more like an obligation, but I do really love her book, The Four Spiritual Laws of Success Anyway. So I just want to say that I’m not dissing Edwin. I like her and she sadly passed not that long ago, but she said that she realized that her unwillingness to forgive was keeping her in debt. She was doing her practice. She realized my unwillingness to forgive is keeping me in debt. And so she did this practice every night for seven nights. She wrote down on paper, “I, Edwin, forgive myself completely 35 times.” I didn’t Google why 35. Anybody know why 35? I don’t know. They must have some spiritual meaning anyway, 35 times.
And then she did it for her father, her mother, her brother, her past relationships, and she makes the connection with reducing the amount of debt in her life.
So I don’t know. I’ve always struggled a little bit with that connection, but I know some people really believe in that, that our unforgiveness creates our debt. I struggle with that. I’m just going to be honest. I struggle with that one a little bit. So think about when we pray, when we do an affirmative prayer, the last step of the prayer is release. We release it, we let it go. We speak our word, we let it go. Forgiveness works the same way. Once we’ve spoken the word, we let it go. And so we want to just make sure that things are flowing in our life. We want to look at, do we have grievances? Are we keeping score somehow? Do we have fear? If I give, there won’t be enough. I could give a whole other talk on that, right? Unworthiness, I don’t deserve to receive.
Self-judgment, especially like the voices of our family and our had about money. But when the flow opens up, we feel lighter and that flow begins with your inner life. You stop bracing, you become grateful, you start noticing the good that’s coming to you and you give in return in whatever form that is.
So we get to choose how we’re going to play things in life, right? We can be like the Sea of Galilee and let the water flow in and out, or we can be like the Dead Sea and we can just let it stagnate. So let’s keep stuff moving. That’s I think how we want to live, right? We want to be happy. So we’re going to do a little Edwin practice as we go into prayer here. And following the prayer, our practitioners are going to offer one minute miracles, which is just a short prayer. They’re going to go stand around the room. So if you would like to get a prayer, you can do that and I’ll just tell you when it’s time. So I invite everyone to turn within now. And I want you to, as you get comfortable with your eyes closed, just make a fist with one of your hands and kind of hold it tight.
This is what it feels like when we hold onto things. It feels tight. It’s how we hold a grudge. It’s how we might hold our fear about money or anything else. It’s how we hold an old judgment about ourselves. And a closed hand can’t give anything and it can’t receive anything either. So now as you sit to receive the prayer, I just invite you to open your hands on your lap, turn your palms up because an open hand can both give and receive. And I’m going to actually ask you to repeat after me. So I’m going to say a statement and then we’re going to say it together. So I, and you’ll say your name, forgive myself completely. Let’s say it together. I, Amy, forgive myself completely. Let’s do it one more time. I, Amy, forgive myself completely. Maybe one more time. Why not?
I, Amy, forgive myself completely. Now silently bring one person in your mind who maybe you’re holding some unforgiveness against. And just in your mind’s eye, just envision the person and say, I forgive you completely. I’m actually going to invite you to say that with me out loud. You don’t need to say their name. Let’s just say it together. I forgive you completely. So let’s move into prayer here. How grateful I am in this moment to come together in the awareness of God, source, spirit, whatever your word is, this infinite divine potential and flow and grace and ease and goodness of life. Prosperity, abundance, wellbeing, love.
And I know that I am one with this perfect divine flow, this love, this grace, this peace, this ease, this prosperity and this abundance. And as I know this for myself, I know this for each and every person who is hearing my words. I know that we are all one with this grace, this ease, this flow, this abundance, this prosperity, this goodness of life, this loving energy of spirit. So from this place of oneness, I just speak my word for each and every one of us. May we have a new and more profound experience this week of giving and receiving in our lives. May we become so aware of the good that is coming to us that it is natural to give and that we give from our whole self, from that wellspring of wellbeing within us. We give our whole self. And I just know that this idea of forgiveness that we began a moment ago, I know that we carry it into the week and we are inspired.
If there is any place that we feel stuck, whether it’s about forgiveness or anything else, I just know that we are divinely inspired to move forward, to release whatever needs to be released so that we can embrace greater love, greater joy, greater peace and wellbeing in our lives. This is what I say yes to for all of us. I’m grateful for it. And together we say, “And so it is.” And I invite the practitioners to line up around the room now. If you’d like to get a minute miracle, just go find a person and just tell them what you want prayer for and they will quickly do a prayer for you. And if you just want to sit in your seat, just take another moment to just enjoy the peace that surrounds you.
